I recently got the chance to see the new Star Wars animated film, The Clone Wars. It’s set during the infamous prequel era; specifically, somewhere between Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith. I think I can sum up my feelings for the film with one word: disappointment.
We knew from the get-go that Clone Wars is nothing but an expanded pilot for the upcoming TV series of the same name. As such, it really does feel like a 90-minute episode, but some of the sequences therein are either too drawn out, or completely unnecessary. The potent video game influence on the film is readily apparent, as well; some movie critics even described the various acts of the movie as “levels”! Watching it, I felt as if I’d played this game about fifty times before.
Some viewers have complained about the rather unique art style in the film; that one I’ll actually leave alone, because a) the artists purposefully tried to create a 3D version of Genndy Tartakovsky’s designs from the original Clone Wars 2D cartoon series, and b) it’s really going to boil down to personal preference. (I, for one, don’t mind the art style at all.)
What I do mind is the subpar animation. While other animated films this year (like WALL•E and Kung Fu Panda) boasted stunning and fluid 3D animation, Clone Wars doesn’t come close. And this from a company world-renowned for special effects? Come on! The walk cycles alone looked like the characters were poorly controlled marionettes. There’s simply no excuse for such piss-poor animation; I’ve seen TV series from smaller companies that look far better.
The prequels were shit upon due to the incredibly poor acting. Fortunately, that’s not a big problem this time around; the voice acting in Clone Wars is quite good, though some of the script choices leave much to be desired. In particular, the writers obviously tried way too hard to make the battle droids funny. We know that they’re not too bright, but they’ve got a way too much “comedic” dialogue assigned to them; some if it’s funny, but a lot of it just doesn’t work. Those clankers are supposed to say “Roger roger!” and not too much else.
Let’s move on to Clone Wars poster child, Ahsoka Tano. Originally, I thought she’d make for an interesting character; she’s an energetic young padawan assigned to the reckless Anakin Skywalker, and I assumed this would continue the black-and-white clashing of ideologies that other master/padawan pairs in the Star Wars saga have had. Well, not quite. While her character is interesting on the surface, Ahsoka manages to become highly annoying within the span of about ten minutes. When they’re not using ridiculous nicknames for each other (she calls him “Skyguy,” while Anakin calls her “Snips”), she’s fulfilling the cliché of “dopey newcomer who causes problems,” complete with campy dialogue. Ahsoka is clearly not supposed to be an idiot, but when she sets off a bunch of proximity alarms that even a blind man could’ve avoided…it’s eye-rollingly bad.
Another problem is the usual “prequel paradox,” as I call it. This a problem with many franchises that make prequels, but Star Wars takes it to new extremes. The prequel paradox is when important characters or events are introduced in a prequel, but we’ve never heard even a passing mention of them before in the original media. (For example, the NX-01 in Star Trek: Enterprise.) In Clone Wars’ case, the paradox is Ahsoka: she’s never been mentioned in Revenge of the Sith, the original trilogy, or anywhere else. Logically, we would assume that she likely gets killed during the war or the subsequent Great Jedi Purge. However, I’ve got a feeling that since Ahsoka is the newcomer that kids are supposed to relate to (not to mention the face of much of the Clone Wars advertising), she’ll survive, and somehow be retconned into the rest of Star Wars media from now on.
On a more random note…what the fuck was up with Homo Ziro the Hutt? Holy shit, I haven’t seen a character that flamboyant since The Birdcage. I can’t help but wonder how many uncomfortable family dinnertime conversations that gave rise to.
While we’re on the subject of the Hutts, the film mangles a longstanding confusion about them. Most people think that the Hutts are a crime clan, when in reality, Hutts are the species, not the clan name. Longtime Star Wars fans know the difference, but casual fans and newcomers understandably may not. Clone Wars makes it even more confusing by referring to the Hutts as both during the course of the film, bouncing back and forth between the two. How the hell did the writers miss that?
Furthermore, Jabba has always been a fan favorite; he was a powerful gangster, a total asshole, and he put Princess Leia in that legendary gold bikini. Clone Wars reveals that Jabba had a son named Rotta. That’s not a problem. The fact that he calls his son “Punky Muffin” most certainly is. What badass crimelord would think up something so inherently stupid? Damn it, George Lucas, leave Jabba alone; you already ruined Darth Vader by making him a whiny bitch.
Alright, enough venting. Let me wrap this up. I suppose if you were a seven- or eight-year-old kid, you might enjoy the Clone Wars film. Instead, if you need to get your Clone Wars cartoon fix, I suggest you check out the original Tartakovsky work.