
This post may contain spoilers. No River Song jokes, please.
Wow, what a shock, I watch Doctor Who. You never would have expected that from a science fiction aficionado, would you? Anyway, today I’m going to babble about my thoughts on the series, with no apparent rhyme or reason connecting my various points. This post may be a bit long and disjointed as a result, and I apologize for that in advance. I’ll do my best to keep it legible.
Before I begin in earnest, I need to get something very important out of the way first. My roommate deserves all of the credit for getting me into Doctor Who. He’s what you’d call a rabid dedicated fan, having loved the series for as long as I’ve known him. He’s got an entire bookcase overflowing with Doctor Who home video releases, novels, and other stuff. (In other words, if this post bores you, it’s technically his fault.)
Prior to meeting my roommate, my only real exposure to Doctor Who was the same as most Americans: reruns on PBS back in the 1980s. I thought it was a cool show as a kid, and enjoyed the adventures of a random time traveler in a massive scarf and floppy hat. I didn’t watch it on a routine basis, though, so I would never call myself a fan.
I’ve only been watching Doctor Who regularly since the 2005 relaunch. As such, most of my commentary will be directed towards Doctor Who over the past six years. There’s so many episodes and novels and whatnot that I’ve missed, that I’m not going to bother trying to get caught up. Sure, I’ll watch random old shows and read a few books here and there, but that’s hardly a concerted effort. Instead, I use the invaluable TARDIS Index File whenever I need information on Doctor Who‘s past. I’m also not interested in any of the spinoffs, like Torchwood or The Sarah Jane Adventures. I’ve seen a few episodes of each, and I was not impressed. They just don’t cut it for me.
I’m going to start with the things about Doctor Who that I enjoy the most. I know this is going against the grain when compared to many fans, but I can honestly say that the current incarnation, the Eleventh Doctor (as played by Matt Smith), is my favorite. The whole “mad scientist” vibe I get from him is right on the money. I know my experience with the classic Doctors is rather limited, except for perhaps the Fourth and Eighth; as I said before, I watched the former on television as a kid, and I’ve read a bunch of novels detailing the latter’s adventures. Regardless, the current Doctor just stands above everything else I’ve seen.
Most folks’ modern favorite is his predecessor, the Tenth Doctor. While I definitely enjoyed David Tennant’s portrayal, there were a few things about his character that I found ridiculous. Most notably, when the Tenth Doctor became visibly angry, it just looked silly and fake. When he’d shout his catchphrase “I…am…talking!” it’s a wonder even the most cowardly villain didn’t just laugh in his face.
The relaunched series does an excellent job of making sure that no prior knowledge of Doctor Who is necessary in order to enjoy it. The Last Great Time War and Big Bang II were both very clever bits of storytelling, and both for the same reason: they provide an in-universe reason to “break” continuity when necessary. Sure, all of the classic adventures still happened…but certain things have been erased by the War, or never happened in the first place due to the entire universe having been “rebooted.” And since the writers rarely details specifics all at once, changes can be made on an episode-by-episode basis.
Then, of course…there’s River Song. I dig time travel stories wherein characters or events are running in opposite directions; the Star Trek: The Next Generation finale “All Good Things…” remains my favorite example of this kind of story. The ongoing River arc works much the same way, starting with her death, and for the most part going back in time from her perspective, but forward with the Doctor and friends. Alex Kingston is more than just a pretty face, as her acting skills are top-notch. She brings a lot of life and personality to River’s character, and that’s just as important as the story.
There’s a few Doctor Who tidbits that I have mixed opinions on. I could talk about how the Doctor needs a different kind of adversary…but I already did that. So let’s move on.
I feel that the acronym TARDIS — Time and Relative Dimension(s) in Space — is a bit outdated. Modern physics sees space and time as the same thing, so the acronym is simply redundant. (Even when you walk across the room, you’re still traveling through time.) I know, I know, it’s there for historical consistency, but there’s no reason the Doctor couldn’t make up something new on the spot; that would be in keeping with his character, anyway.
The Doctor Who relaunch logo and the slight redesign that followed were both awful. That’s the kind of messy work that would’ve earned me failing marks back in art school. The current logo introduced in 2010 (and seen at the top of this post), is much better. Making the TARDIS itself part of the logo? A fantastic idea! It’s a wonder no one thought of it sooner.
I’ve heard numerous grumblings about how the Doctor’s sonic screwdriver far too often functions as a “magic wand.” I know it’s really there to sell toys (which, in my case at least, certainly worked; I own a few replicas), but I’ll agree that its overuse did get rather tiresome during the Tenth Doctor’s run. The Doctor’s seling point is his supreme intelligence and wit; simply waving a device to fix any and all problems belies that.
Okay, I’ve been positive long enough. There’s a bunch of things with Doctor Who that I don’t like at all.
I’m willing to sweep a lot of minor stuff under the rug; Doctor Who is designed as an all-ages program, after all, so plenty of things adults may find dumb are clearly intended for children, and that’s fine. For example, many villains overenunciate their speech; that makes it obvious to kids that they’re the bad guys. The same goes for the various catchphrases spouted off by the Doctor and many others. I’m not a fan of them, but I understand why they’re included; kids love that shit. (As do some of the more obsessive fans, but I just ignore them.)
Furthermore, issues due to dramatic license also get a pass. Yes, we know that the TARDIS or other ships shouldn’t make a damned sound in the emptiness of space, but that’s not very exciting, now is it? I’m also willing to forgive problems due to obvious budgetary constraints. For the first few seasons of the relaunch, many of the special effects looked outdated and downright awful. Still, the powers-that-be did they best they could with what they had.
On to the stuff which receives no quarter. While the Doctor and his companions are always well-acted, sometimes the supporting cast leaves a lot to be desired. A random character with one or two lines is forgivable if they’re not up to snuff, but sometimes other characters central to the episode are so poorly acted that it brings the whole thing crashing down. Prime examples are the Empress of the Racnoss from “Runaway Bride,” or the Family of Blood from the episode of the same name. This goes above and beyond overacting because they’re villains (see my earlier point); I haven’t seen acting that lame since a junior high school play.
My biggest beef, however, is the gaping plot holes found in far too many episodes. I don’t mind minor continuity errors, or even more bigger ones that might contradict episodes from decades past. I’m talking about nonsensical plots within episodes or seasons themselves. More often than not, these upend the entire story, with the end result ultimately making no sense at all.
“Victory of the Daleks” had a pair of whoppers. The first is a flight of Spitfire aircraft that were modified for space travel. That concept in and of itself is no big deal, but it’s how the episode handled it that was laughably bad. How did the Spitfires fly into orbit? By generating a small forcefield around the plane filled with air. Even a rudimentary knowledge of airplane mechanics disproves this entire plot point. Aircraft require vast swaths of atmosphere in order to travel; that’s why they’re called aircraft. A tiny bubble wouldn’t allow an airplane to fly in an airless environment any more than a treadmill would allow a car to drive on water. Furthermore, the combustion engines the planes used for flight would’ve burned up the small amount of air inside the bubble rather quickly, as well as filling it with noxious exhaust. Those poor pilots wouldn’t live very long.
The other problem is that towards the end of the episode, it’s revealed that the scientist Dr. Bracewell is actually an android, created as a weapon by the Daleks. He was programmed with false memories and and all that jazz to be the perfect mole. (He’s like a Cylon sleeper agent from Battlestar Galactica.) The Daleks placed a bomb in him as a failsafe, and when their plan fails, the bomb starts to count down. How does the Doctor save the day? By having Bracewell convince himself that he’s really human, regardless of his metal body. This made no sense whatsoever; cripes, if all it takes to defuse an explosive is emotion, then just about anybody could be a one-man bomb squad!
The duology of “The Empty Child” and “The Doctor Dances” is another eye-roller. Alien nanobots scanned a badly hurt human child, and since they’d never encountered humans before, the ‘bots thought that was our default configuration. So, when they came into contact with other people, the ‘bots altered them to also have the same gas mask, hand scar, and speech pattern as the little boy. That’s all well and good…except that the ‘bots should have also made the affected people smaller, and changed their clothes and hair accordingly…in other words, it should have made all of the other folks look exactly like the original child. That’s how the ‘bots worked, after all. The episode’s plot falls apart if they’re doing a half-assed job! The fact that the Doctor solved the problem by literally waving his hands like a magician didn’t help, either, but that’s less of a plot hole and more of a stupid plot device.
Speaking of poor plot devices, nothing trumps the episode “Bad Wolf.” This was nothing more than a commercial for The Weakest Link, Big Brother, and What Not to Wear. That’s not a plot hole, but it’s goddamned insulting. I want to watch Doctor Who, not ads! Blatant product placement pisses me off, and this was one of the most egregious examples I’d ever seen.
Last but not least, there’s plenty of just plain shitty episodes, but that’s nothing unique to Doctor Who. Every television program has moments we’d rather forget. I do need to point out, though, that my roommate — yes, the hardcore Doctor Who fan — referred to “Love and Monsters” as the worst episode of any television show he’d ever seen.
I’ve seen plenty of Doctor Who apologists just brush these serious problems off or even defend them, and that makes me weep for the future of science fiction. Now, while any series is worthy of criticism in some form, Doctor Who is definitely a program whose apologists tend to shout louder than most. At least, they do in America. I’d imagine British fans are a bit more reserved, as Doctor Who is not “new” for them. There’s a Doctor Who thread on most of the message boards I frequent…and I’ve learned to steer clear. I’m sure most fans are level-headed, but there’s enough bad eggs to make forum discussions unworthy of my time.
I think I’ve rambled long enough at this point. I’m sure after this post goes live, I’ll think of about fifteen things I’d missed, complete with an audible curse word or two. Oh well. Perhaps I’ll do a sequel post somewhere down the line? Chime in with your comments if that’s something you’d like to read. (Or beg me not to write about Doctor Who ever again. It’s up to you.)
On a final random note, those t-shirts emblazoned with “You Never Forget Your First Doctor” are just plain creepy.